As I was ploughing through my daily plate of 15 full-size scotch eggs this morning, I was reflecting on the latest contenders in Ultimate 1990s Number One, my series in which I rate every number one in the 1990s UK singles chart.
Do you know what I concluded? Scotch eggs are great. I really love these scotch eggs. The ten chart-toppers I'm about to feature have some interesting aspects, but these crumb-smeared porky eggballs really are hitting the mark.
I think I might vomit. Bring on the contenders!
The contenders
All Saints: Never Ever | Blondie: Maria | East 17: Stay Another Day | Freddie Mercury: Living on My Own | Meat Loaf: I'd Do Anything for Love (But I Won't Do That) | Oasis: D'You Know What I Mean? | Spacedust: Gym and Tonic | Steps: Heartbeat / Tragedy | The Verve: The Drugs Don't Work | White Town: Your Woman
I won't do these
It is a well-established fact that Meatloaf would do anything for love. As the best-selling single of 1993 clearly states, he knows it's true and that's a fact. However, the one thing Meatloat won't do for love is proceed any further in my Ultimate 90s competition. His histrionic handkerchief-clutching has no place here.
Like the Meatloaf song, I found Oasis's third chart-topper D'You Know What I Mean? to be excessive. With its overbearing strings and uninspired lyrics, it represented Oasis's descent into their OASIS period (Overblown And Stale Indie Sludge). They gain points for using morse code, but dash dash / dot / dot dot dot dot.
An actual tragedy
I would like to eliminate two further contestants. Steps' take on Tragedy is, compared to the BeeGees original, a tragedy. In the video for its other A-side Heartbeat, they battle a bunch of dwarfs. This was back in the 1990s, in the socially careless era of Friends' casual homophobia, but surely that was a, er, Steps too far.
By the time The Verve hit number one with the maudlin melodrama The Drugs Don't Work. they had lost some of their, er, verve. In your face, previous paragraph, that was way better than the Steps joke. Still, it's a bit of a tune, and sometimes the drugs don't indeed work, and we are greateful for their medical wisdom. It is eliminated because I'm looking for bleepy hits not weepy hits.
Hacienda flashback
The following tracks are undoubtedly tunes, indeed possibly bangers, but none of them progress in this competition because their bleepiness is either absent or inadequate.
I have a vague memory of seeing the early, unsuccessful version of All Saints. It may have been a ZTT Records showcase, and I think it was at the Hacienda. They were the best band of the night, but they wouldn't enjoy success until the Appleton sisters joined. Although Never Ever was made amid song writing tensions, it achieved more pre-sales than any other song in UK history. A banger.
Knocking The Offspring off the number one spot wasn't on my bingo card for Blondie. They hadn't topped the singles chart since the early 1980s. Maria came with dance remixes by Talvin Singh and NYC producers Soul Solution, with Singh totally ripping the track into fractals of drum 'n' bass tabla goodness.
As I was saying to Santa Claus the other day, we haven't had a decent Christmas number one hit for ages. East 17's Stay Another Day was a banger with baubles on. Scally elf Brian Harvey has cut quite a trouble figure in recent years. You should check out The Black Dog's Conspiracy Tapes featuring Brian's wilder rants – I think it's great, although Santa hates it because he only likes 15th century madrigals and mumble rap.
We are (not) the champions
It would be awful to make you wade through this whole blog post only for me to tell you that none of these contenders are good enough to continue in the Ultimate 90s competition. It would be a waste of your time, it would be a waste of my time, and it probably contravenes some kind of blogging law. Fingers crossed...
When Bob Sinclair fluked a number one in summer 1998, it rode a wave of energetic French house music. But Gym & Tonic has problems. Small problem: it is inferior to the track it samples, Stardust's Music Sounds Better With You. Bigger problem: it is inferior to the original Gym Tonic by Daft Punk's Thomas Bangalter which featured workout vocals by Jane Fonda. Sorry, Bob, it's a no.
I never thought I'd say this, but here's a thumping dance tune from Freddie Mercury. Everyone's favourite moustachioed prancer dug out Living On My Own from his 1985 solo album, asked Belgian production outfit No More Brothers to remix it, and lo and behold he's knocking Take That off the number one spot. Shame he wasn't around to appreciate the song's new-found success. My only issue is that's it's annoying. Really annoying. The bit when he goes all scat? The way he says "monkey business"? Proper rubs me up the wrong way.
Please, let's have one good track. Please. I bow to the blogging gods, deliver us from musical mediocrity. PLEASE.
Worth Whiting for (sorry)
Just when I thought all was lost, here comes White Town (pictured) with the glorious Your Woman. I remember getting this sent before release, and it was so lo-fi, I wouldn't have predicted the success it had. Adamski had popularised the 'keyboard wizard' DIY synth thing years earlier, but here was a bedroom musician knocking Tori Amos off the top spot. Jyoti Mishra's still going strong, posting music programming videos, and with singles varying from sunny pop rock to dirty acid techno.
Thank you, White Town, you've saved it. Your Woman goes through to the Ultimate 90s final.